The Nazi Cheeseburger is a character who appeared in Cody's Happy Hanukkah! and Substitute Teacher!. He is a Nazi, and is beaten yearly by Tyrone and his family on Hanukkah. In Substitute Teacher!, Judy Nutkiss claims it wasn't Hitler who caused the Holocaust, but actually, The Nazi Cheeseburger killed all the Jewish people. All the while, Cody (her son), tells Junior and Joseph (who are currently believing Judy) that what she is saying is false information.
- He was (supposedly) responsible for the Holocaust.
- He was (supposedly) responsible for Hitlers reign of power over Nazi Germany.
- Cheeseburgers are considered food that isn't kosher (acceptable towards the Jewish religion) due to mixtures of milk and meat, so his portrayal as a Nazi might be intentional.
- Burgers were also first made in Hamburg, Germany, so it also could be intentional in that way.
- He was a piñata in Cody's Happy Hanukkah!
- The Nazi Cheeseburger is actually just a Cheeseburger piñata with a Nazi symbol taped to his forehead.