Makes Bad Decisions Guy is one of the younger brothers of Brooklyn T. Guy and a crazy person who is a cannibal. He is the main antagonist of Jeffy's Foster Home! . Brooklyn T. Guy drops off Jeffy and tells him to stay there as it was his Foster home.

He appears to look the same as Brooklyn T. Guy except that some of his Body parts are missing such as his ears.


Makes Bad Decisions Guy is mentally crazy and acts quickly as possible which leads to either becoming suddenly angry or triggered. Makes Bad Decisions Guy also is cannibalistic, as he is seen eating a severed arm that his friend Tim got him. He also is somewhat artistic with how he creates sculptures with candy. Based on his name demeanor and appearance, he apparently does drugs.

Likes and Dislikes


  • Eating body parts (mostly arms)
  • Tim
  • Candy Sculptures
  • Worms
  • Sharks



  • He might be gay due to the fact that he sleeps with Tim on couch and Tim is the only one that lives with him.
  • He seems to be based off Ed Gein, a real life serial killer from the 1950s and or Nubbins sawyer from the Texas chainsaw massacre. As makes bad decisions guy and nubbins both are Cannibals and mentally unstable, while Ed Gein made corpses out of furniture and a foot can be seen in the background making bad decision guy half based on Ed Gein
  • Makes Bad Decisions is the second puppet to possess Brooklyn T. Guy's form, the first Being Does Bad Things Guy except that he has different body features most likely due to how Does Bad Things Guy being Brooklyn T. Guy's only identical looking brother.
  • He originates from a Unboxing video where Logan receives him with the Firefighter outfit on.


Do you like Makes Bad Decisions Guy?

The poll was created at 03:48 on June 25, 2019, and so far 109 people voted.
Main characters MarioBowserBlack YoshiChef Pee PeeBowser JuniorJosephCodyShrekRosalinaJeffyBrooklyn T. Guy
Recurring characters GoodmanJackie ChuTyroneJudy
Minor characters Doofy The DragonToadCharleyyyTony The TigerWoodyMargaretLuigiCraig The DevilScrewballMr. PigPeachThomasKenPatrickPink YoshiPrincipal SteinbeckHarold WilfredJudyDonkey KongDiddy KongGolden ThomasHanselKirbyChris the CucumberFelipeThe RatEmily ColemanPixie GoblinSamanthaWarioWaluigiSimmonsBrooklyn Guy's WifeTyreeseTom BradyMr. WinkleCarlosCandyCandy's FatherMickey MouseRay CheesyD-Money JuniorJackie TwuMine! BirdBaby MarioLoan DolphinSonicChef Poo PooChompyBully BillThe AlienDr. Fredrick FinkleshitsJacques Pierre FrançoisCrystalHarambeBarack ObamaMr. DinkleThe Alien's WifeTerranceMelvinDoes Bad Things GuyGumboDrawing JeffyMr. MagooCookie Monster
One-Time characters Dark Matter in my ShortsChef LuigiThe CrocodileElectrician's SonJoseph's GirlfriendRemySheila PerkinsPopeyeD-Money SeniorThe Cat In The HatDoofy's Ex-WifeBirdoBully Bill's DadPolly The ParrotKidnapperKatyJoseph's DadMr. BonesFeebeeJeff The KillerKiller ClownOther Killer ClownChazJunior JuniorStephen HawkingPee Pee SuckWormyNancy JeffyEaster Bunny GenieRussian SpyPiggieGreen Bean GiantPoofGreg the PigDewey DonediditCatherine CatfishBungholeShelbyKool-Aid ManBearyRichard GoodmanSharkyBabiesBig BwahBoofy the MooseChester the ChickenMore...
Classic Characters Big RedKung PowBaby PeachThe RatTyreeseTaco Bell ChihuahuaMama LuigiSpeedyPimpster GoombaSkittlesShrek JuniorTalibanBlueChadKing PigRay the pigHelmet PigYoshiCeciliaKing StrongbottomTannerKoopa TroopaAtsoBrown ElephantLazlo
Cast Logan ThirtyacreLovell StantonLance ThirtyacreChris NethertonChilly JimenezElaina KeyesTito JimenezJulian JimenezDonald RodriguezRebecca
[How does it work?]
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.