"Jeffy's Pet Shark!" is the 447th episode of SML Movies.
The video starts with Jeffy playing with a triangle instrument, and he claims to Mario that every time he hears a ding sound, he just pooped in his pants. Jeffy dings the triangle, and starts doing it over and over again. Then, the doorbell rings.
Brooklyn T. Guy is at the door with a tank top on, and he asks if Mario wants to go fishing. Mario doesn’t feel like it but then says yes. He doesn’t have anyone to watch Jeffy, though, so Brooklyn Guy gets frustrated when Mario says he has to bring Jeffy, but he lets him anyway.
Jeffy has the triangle around his neck while dinging it. Mario asks Jeffy if he wants to go fishing with them, and Jeffy says yes. Mario takes the triangle off his neck, and they leave to go fishing.
Mario, Jeffy, and Brooklyn Guy are on the boat, and in Brooklyn Guy’s opinion, the best spot in the ocean because he catches like 50 fish whenever he’s there. However, there is one rule: None of them are allowed to catch a shark, since it's illegal. They then start fishing.
Brooklyn T. Guy’s fishing pole is a blue Star Wars lightsaber, but he says it’s red. He throws the pole in the water, and so does Jeffy. After so much time of waiting, Jeffy finally has a catch. He pulls his pole in, and apparently, his catch is a shark. Jeffy and the shark suddenly scream at each other. Mario and Brooklyn Guy hear it, and they see the shark on the boat. Jeffy wants to keep the shark as his pet, but Mario tells him to throw it back in. Jeffy says his infamous line, “I don’t have to” and Mario says he does have to and he ”obeys” and secretly puts the shark in the cooler. He asks to go because someone pooped in his pants, and Mario and Brooklyn Guy agree.
At home, Mario and Brooklyn Guy complained about how the fishing trip sucked when Jeffy shows up with the cooler. He then brings the cooler into the bathroom and Brooklyn Guy leaves.
In the bathroom, Jeffy dumps the shark into a bathtub, causing it to scream again and Mario runs into the bathroom. Jeffy blocks the shark from him and Mario then leaves. The shark says he's hungry and Jeffy gets him gummy worms. The shark doesn't like it so Jeffy brought him an egg and a box of Cheerios. The shark doesn't want those either and begged Jeffy for cheese. Jeffy brings the shark a cup of macaroni and cheese and he decided to take a picture of him and the shark and send it to the internet.
Later, Brooklyn Guy returns as a cop because he received Jeffy's photo. He and Mario goes in the bathroom and finds Jeffy watching the shark still eating macaroni and cheese. The three of them then return to the ocean and Jeffy said his goodbyes to the shark and tosses it into the water. The shark gets eaten by a bigger shark and Jeffy mistook it for his pet shark's mommy.
When he goes to tell the others, Brooklyn Guy tells him what really happened and says that the shark is dead, prompting Jeffy to sob, annoying Mario and Brooklyn Guy. The video ends as Mario and Jeffy went back home and Mario tolds Jeffy to learn his lesson about not bringing a shark home and keep it as a pet and Jeffy walks into his room crying over a shark was dead off-screen.
- Brooklyn T. Guy
- Shark Puppet
- Debra (indirectly mentioned as 'whale')
- Shark Who Killed Shark Puppet
- Sharky was portrayed by The Shark Puppet, which is a multi-platform channel that does skits with the puppet. Their channel can be viewed here: https://www.youtube.com/sharkpuppet.
- This is the first video of July 2019.
- This is the longest break since SML Movies it took 18 days till a new video came.
- This is Jeffy and Mario's first appearance on SuperBowserLogan.
- This is the first SML Movie that was uploaded on SuperBowserLogan due to SuperLuigiLogan being demonetized.
- "S**t" (x2), and f**k are censored.
- The swearing was censored by farting noises instead of beeping noises due to beeping noises not being family-friendly.
- This video marks the beginning of SML's second "family friendly" streak.
- This is the first video to be uploaded on SuperBowserLogan since Logan Plays Quick Draw!.
- At some point in the time in the BTS video, Shark Puppet’s actor (face) can be seen revealing his true identity.
- This video is actually the first major collab video since 2009 with DeStorm in the SuperMarioLogan Theme Song. This was also planned for months beforehand. This is currently the only and most viewed SML collaboration.
- This video was made 5 days after Logan purposed to Chilly.
- Shark Puppet has now collaborated with Logan Paul and other YouTubers, prompting a possible future Logan Paul and SML crossover.
- This is the same location used in the SML Movies The Fishing Trip! and Sunken.
- This is the first video to be promoted on both SuperMarioLogan and SuperLuigiLogan, the second and last video being Jeffy's Magical Pencil!.
- In the thumbnail, Jeffy is seen holding a wedge of cheese. But in the video, he actually gave the Shark Puppet a cup of macaroni and cheese.