"Jeffy's Magical Pencil!" is the 454th episode of SML Movies.
Jeffy has a magical pencil!
It's arts and crafts day at Y U DUMB? Elementary School, and the project was creating a message on paper with glitter. Junior makes a "Cody's mom is fat" joke out of it, and Joseph asks for paper from Cody because he is poor and does not have any.
Jeffy decides to mix up the glitter, but he does not want to get any on his hands, so he uses his pencil. He mixes up the glitter, covering it in glitter. Bully Bill writes 'Doofus' on his paper and shows it to Jeffy, and he calls him nose-like pirate ship cannonball looking. He then turns him into a pirate with his pencil, which had become magical. Bully Bill sings to Jeffy calling him a doofus in the melody of the Spongebob theme song. So Jeffy beats him up with a giant pencil. Junior, Joseph, and Cody all show their projects to each other, and Jackie Chu fails Jeffy, so Jeffy turns him into a Charizard.
After school, Jeffy shows his pencil to Mario, who doesn't believe its magic at first, so he uses it to turn him into a lion to prove it. Mario is unhappy and asks to be changed back, but Jeffy says he doesn't know how. So Mario calls the doctor. Brooklyn Guy arrives, and cracks up an endless amount of jokes, ticking Mario off, and he mauls him in the left eye out of anger after too many jokes.
Brooklyn Guy gets band-aids on his head, and then suggests Jeffy TRIES to turn him back to normal. Jeffy tries, and turns Mario into a Zombie from Minecraft. Brooklyn Guy asks for his face to be fixed, but is instead turned into a dragon. Jeffy says he can't control WHAT they turn into with the pencil, then leaves to try and find out. Mario and Brooklyn Guy then fly to McDonald's.
Junior and his friends start playing 'Stack Cups' before Jeffy interrupts, turning Cody into a mermaid, Joseph into a Mr. Potato Head with no arms and just a tongue, and Junior into Thomas. They are happy with it however, and go to try out their new forms.
Mario and Brooklyn Guy come back after being kicked out of McDonald's, but Mario at least has a brain to eat. Brooklyn Guy tries playing Operation, but his hands are too big. Jeffy returns, and Mario gives him baby arugula for dinner. Jeffy turns it into chocolate cake, which has mold on it, so Mario makes him wash his hands. Jeffy washes his hands, and his pencil, removing the glitter, and magic. This turns everyone back to normal, and Brooklyn Guy cracks up another joke about being glad that the video didn't "Drag-ON" too long.
- Jackie Chu (Becomes Charizard at 3:18)
- Bowser Junior (Becomes Thomas at 8:15)
- Cody (Becomes a mermaid at 7:31)
- Joseph (Becomes a Mr. Potato Head without arms at 7:54)
- Bully Bill (Becomes a pirate at 1:57)
- Mario (Becomes a lion at 3:58 and a Minecraft Zombie at 5:33)
- Brooklyn T. Guy (Becomes a dragon at 5:53)
- This is the first video of August 2019.
- This videos thumbnail introduces a new happy Jeffy variant.
- This video is the inspiration of an “in the making Jeffy fangame for the game boy” being made by Bigjawed.
- Joseph states that the Little Mermaid is black, this is a reference to Halle Berry's casting as Ariel in the upcoming live-action Little Mermaid movie.
- The bell that Cody, Joseph, and Junior use is the same bell that Jeffy used in Jeffy Breaks His Leg!.
- This video was requested by a fan in a recent Chilly vlog.
- The lion puppet is same one that was used in Bowser Junior's Imaginary Friend!, Jeffy Gets Help! and Schizophrenia Case Study. It is also the same puppet used for Leppy the Lion, Chef Pee Pee's Imaginary Friend.
- After Brooklyn T. Guy is turned into a dragon, he says that he'll "marry a donkey", this is a reference to the Shrek franchise, in which Donkey is married to a dragon.
- When Junior turns into Thomas, he says “I think I can.” This is a line said in the children's story, ”The Little Engine That Could.”
- Bully Bill calls Jeffy a doofus in this video instead of a retard, likely because "retard" is grounds for demonetization.
- When Bully Bill becomes a pirate, he makes two references to SpongeBob SquarePants: he laughs like Mr. Krabs, and he insults Jeffy by singing him a parody of the SpongeBob SquarePants Theme Song.
- This is one of the very few times in which Mario serves Jeffy another food besides green beans or something unusual such as blue jawbreaker sized gumballs.
- This is the first video where Brooklyn T. Guy makes Family-Friendly comedy, and not sex jokes.
- An alternative Sharon puppet was used for when Cody turned into a mermaid.
- This is the second and last video to be promoted on both SuperMarioLogan and SuperLuigiLogan, the first video being Jeffy's Pet Shark!.
- This episode was uploaded 6 years after "A Bird Problem".
- If everything went back to normal after Jeffy washed the glitter off his pencil, then the chocolate cake should have changed back to baby arugula as well. It could be that the magic only works on people, or it changed after the video had ended.
- On the description, the word magical was misspelled. It said Jeffy has a magial pencil!. It was meant to say Jeffy has a magical pencil!.
- At 6:51 Junior calls Joseph, Joey.