"Jeffy's Lie!" is the 497th episode of SML Movies.
Jeffy tells a huge lie!
The episode starts off with Jeffy holding a baseball and asks Mario to throw the baseball in his eye so he could see what it's like to be a bat. Mario, of course, refuses to do so, which makes Jeffy throw the baseball at Mario's eye, giving him a black eye. Angry at him, Mario tells Jeffy to go outside and ask someone else to hit him with the baseball. Jeffy goes outside to see Patrick acting like a cow. After making animal noises at each other, Jeffy asks Patrick to throw the baseball at his eye. Patrick agrees to do so and throws the baseball at Jeffy's eye giving him a black eye. The next day Jeffy goes to school. Jackie Chu says it's special guest day and introduces Brooklyn T. Guy as the special guest, as an officer. While he is explaining how his job as a cop is like for him, Junior and Cody notice Jeffy's black eye, thinking he did something cool. Jeffy wanting to look cool attempts to lie and say what happened but is interrupted by Brooklyn Guy. Because Brooklyn Guy is mad at them for ignoring him. Brooklyn Guy forces Jeffy to come in front of the class to tell his story. Jeffy comes in front of the class to tell his story, Jeffy says that there was a fire with 45 babies inside which he rescued by making a diaper parachute, but then Godzilla came out from the underground and pokes Jeffy in the eye giving him his black eye. Jeffy punches Godzilla into space, saving the world. Of course, everyone believed him and cheered for him. Jeffy was shown on the news being awarded 2 medals in his honor. Mario, who was the news was shocked to hear this. Then Brooklyn Guy comes him saying that Mario should be proud to have a hero for a son. Brooklyn Guy then notices Mario's black eye. Mario, for some reason, lies and said that Godzilla also gave him his black eye by being hit by his tail. Brooklyn Guy then leaves, now he went gone, Mario is shown furiously at Jeffy for lying to the whole world, although Jeffy doesn't care too much about the situation. Patrick comes in and calls Jeffy a liar. Some time has passed, and Mario turns on the news to see that there's a hospital that caught fire with 50 babies trapped inside saying that all the firefighters quit, thinking that Jeffy will save the babies. Mario tells Jeffy to do something but Jeffy "turned off" his ears. Brooklyn Guy comes in to tell Jeffy to help, but Mario ends up telling the truth saying that Jeffy lied about being a hero. Brooklyn Guy says that he'll save the babies, but only ends up rescuing 4 and says that Jeffy is a liar. The episode ends with Jeffy "turning off" his ears again.
- Brooklyn T. Guy
- Jackie Chu
- Bowser Junior
- Nancy (mentioned)
- Sharon (mentioned)
- Mrs. Coleman (mentioned)
- Godzilla (thumbnail; animations)
- 3 Unnamed FireFighters (animations)
- Babies (reality; animations)
- Benjamin Goodman (animation)
- This is the fourth time Nicktendo animated part of the video.
- The black eye Jeffy in this video is the same puppet that was used in "Picture Day!".
- The Godzilla design seen in the thumbnail is Godzilla's fourth form from the 2016 film Shin Godzilla. The design in the Nicktendo segments, meanwhile, is based on the Legendary Pictures design used in their MonsterVerse films.
- Over all, this is the first time Godzilla has ever physically appeared on SML. He appears in the Nicktendo animation portion of it.
- Bowser Junior and Cody appear as Koopas in school. This means Jackie Chu either stopped caring, or Logan retired the human puppets due to them ultimately not being necessary. Not to mention that a lot of people hated the puppets, including Logan himself.
- "Rugs with a D in front of it" is said instead of drugs to avoid demonetization.
- It is revealed that Patrick's mother in is prison, likely for child neglect. This explains why he appears along with a step-mom in "Jeffy's New Dad!".
- This episode is similar to the SpongeBob SquarePants episode Blackened Sponge, where both main characters get a black eye and cover it up saying they got it after doing something awesome/heroic.
- This video marks the Return Of Nicktendo Animations Segments since "Black Yoshi's Call of Duty Modern Warfare!".
- This marks the first mention of Nancy since "Jeffy's Sister Returns!".
- This is the second video to uploaded on Mario Day; first is "Heartbroken!", which was upload one year before this video.
- In Nicktendo's animation, one of the babies Jeffy saved was Benjamin Goodman.
- It's possible that Patrick could have been the one who lit the building on fire with 50 Babies in it because he said to Jeffy "We'll see who the real hero is, next time a building catches fire", and even some people in the comments said that he could have been the one that lit the building on fire, but it's unknown if he did it or not just to see who the real hero was if the building catches fire.
- Note: Bully Bill did not appear In the video.
- In Jeffy's story, Godzilla says he's hungry for babies. However, outside of a scene cut from the 1989 film Godzilla vs. Biollante, Godzilla is not a carnivore, but instead absorbs radiation since his heart is a literal nuclear reactor.
- However, Jeffy was obviously lying, so he might have simply made up facts about Godzilla
- However, this is only true with the Heisei Godzilla, but with MonsterVerse Godzilla is unknown because the Heisei Godzilla and the MonsterVerse Godzilla are separate and they don't belong in the same continuity.
- Bully Bill is not seen in his seat.