Gary is a two-time character who first appeared in Cody's Real Dad! as a pizza delivery man for 30 Second Sammy's; a pizza place that guarantees that your pizza will be delivered in 30 seconds or less, or it's free. Later in the episode, it was revealed that Gary is Cody's real dad as when Gary went over to Cody's house to initially deliver as Judy confesses to Tyrone that 14 years ago, she ordered a pizza, but she couldn't pay for it (inciting that she did something else to make up the lost money) and was doing it for 14 years. However, Gary ends up being knocked out by Tyrone when he and Tyrone were fighting, which this causes Gary to lose his memory, therefore no one believes him that he had a biological son, but it was revealed that Brooklyn Guy was paid to lie to him about losing his memory and having no son.