| Please note the following:
The content in this page or section has been made non-canon to the main SuperMarioLogan universe.
Chef Pee Pee is the new night guard at Freddy Fazbear's pizza!
Chef Pee Pee was wearing a black t-shirt and saying that he hates his life and crying about not having a new job when Goodman gives him his old clothes.
But Goodman spoils by saying that Chef Pee Pee has been given security duty at Freddy Fazbear's pizza. Goodman remarks that he's going to stay there for 5 nights, hence the title of the popular game "Five Nights at Freddy's".
Goodman mentions that there were a few other security guards before him, but they all went missing.
Chef Pee Pee asks how much they pay and Goodman says that they pay $100 per week. Chef Pee Pee thinks that the payment sucks but it's still better than Bowser's pay so he accepts.
After hours, Chef Pee Pee is patrolling the area and begins starving. Chef Pee Pee finds the kitchen door locked, and unlocks it. He sees frozen pizza and tries to cook it, but screams when he sees bloody writings.
Chef Pee Pee checks the security cameras, and he is shocked to see that the animatronics, which was there before, we're no longer there. Chef Pee Pee is now frightened when goes to check the puppets were not there. Chef Pee Pee, now frightened, wants to get the hell out of there. He thinks if he stays in the room, nothing will go wrong. Then he hears footsteps and sees Foxy and quickly shuts the door and tells himself he's too beautiful to die. Then he says he'll work one night and then he'll quit the job.
Chef Pee Pee doesn't hear anything and opens the door and Freddy starts screaming and he immediately closes the door. Then he decided to fight back, which he finds a pen and a notebook that reads You're Next - Chica. Then he finds Chica on the camera and suspects she's outside. So Chef Pee Pee uses a stapler to attack Chica.
After that, the building runs out of power. Then Freddy jumpscares him and start dragging Chef Pee Pee. Chef Pee Pee begs him to spare his life and he starts noticing that they were looking at something which was a hot pizza. Chef Pee Pee figured out they just wanted him to have some pizza. Then the video ends saying to be continued ending with a jump scare.
- Chef Pee Pee
- Officer Goodman
- Freddy Fazbear
- Phone Guy
- Murder Victim
- Unknown Cops (audio only)
- Bowser (mentioned)
- The office that Chef Pee Pee was doing his job in was a real office in a building, not Logan's apartment.
- The FNAF puppets were sewn by Logan and his friends prior to this video.
- The FNAF puppets were originally sent from a girl in Italy but they never came to Pensacola.
- Bonnie disappeared from the stage but was nowhere to be seen.
- dabhdude was present while Logan edited the video
- At 8:56 Logan was originally going to have Freddy Fazbear humming. However, this would have used a Foxy line, which dabhdude ended up pointing out during editing.
- The SML Question is only 3 seconds long.
- The selected camera is not highlighted so it is confusing which camera is which.
- This is the fourth video to end with a jump scare, the first being "Mario's Nightmare", the second being "Bowser Junior's Sleepover" and the third being "Cody's Sleepover".
- This is also the second video to end with an FNAF jumpscare, the first being Bowser Junior's Sleepover.
- This is the first Chef Pee Pee Quits! installment where neither Bowser nor Bowser Junior appears.
- At 4:55, Freddy can be seen near the door carefully.
- Freddy's jumpscare sound clip was ripped from the first FNAF game. It was used 3 times.
- At 2:55 it says "12:00 AM" in the upper right corner of the screen. However, after it cuts at 2:56, all it says is ":AM."
- Bonnie was seen in the camera, but however, he was nowhere to be seen, it is possible that he was hiding somewhere.
- When the video was uploaded, the thumbnail said 4 instead of 5. However, a few days later it was fixed.
- On 0:14 Lance's nose can be seen when Goodman is seen