It’s finally time. The ultimate post from me. Let’s just get this over with.
I‘ll first show the tier list, and then I’ll list my top 10 favorite and least favorite videos from this year. Also, this tier list apparently doesn’t include the videos after FNAF 4 for some reason, so I’ll tell where they would be placed at the bottom of the tier list image.
Listed all in order from worst to best, here’s the list!
The Grinch would be located in C tier, in between “Jeffy The Elf” and “Jeffy’s Dare.”
Junior’s Scary Bump would be located in D tier, in between “Jeffy’s Pregnancy Scare” and “Jeffy Gets Knocked Out.”
Jeffy Catches a Predator would be located in B tier, in between “Saving The Park” and “SCREAM.”
And Chef Pee Pee’s Kiss would be located in the Abysmal tier, in between “Marvin The Pool Boy” and “Jeffy’s Voice Problem.”
Now for the top 10s.
TOP 10 BEST:
10 - FNAF: Just a fun and spooky video that fitted perfectly on my alley.
9 - The Opposite Ray: A creative and funny video that exceeded my expectations.
8 - Junior’s Big Playtime: A great comeback to a solid series.
7 - Jeffy Ball Z Part 4: A fun, action-packed parody.
6 - FNAF 4: The scariest out of the 4 videos in the series, and I enjoyed it a lot.
5 - Jeffy Ball Z Part 3: The best of the JBZ series and the funniest out of them all.
4 - The Monster Mash: A fun, creative, and unique video. Should’ve been the Halloween special.
3 - FNAF 3: The best of the FNAF series with many surprises and interesting moments.
2 - Breaking Bad: A parody that fit perfectly for this series.
1 - Junior’s Deadly Idea: While not 10/10 worthy, it’s definitely one of the best SML videos in the 2020 decade, and also the funniest.
TOP 10 WORST:
10 - Cody’s Hot Potion: The video that MADE me want to quit SML, and the whole reason I held this precedent in the first place.
9 - Goodman’s Wife: Mario gets accused of cheating for the 5 quadrillionth time, what a shocker!
8 - Jeffy’s Gamer Girl Problem: A disgusting video that serves no right to exist.
7 - Marvin The Pool Boy: Marvin gets sexually harassed for 11 minutes straight. Nothin’ else to say.
6 - Chef Pee Pee’s Kiss: One of the most annoying videos and a horrible way to end 2023 and my experience in general.
5 - Jeffy’s Voice Problem: A nothing video that is kind of the prequel to a certain video I’ll get to.
4 - No Invite: Cody torture at its worst. Junior and Joseph are the clear culprits here, don’t make any excuses otherwise.
3 - Jeffy Plays Genshin Impact: A literal advertisement that was insufferable to watch. Logan had already gotten backlash from Jeffy’s 19th Birthday prior to this video’s upload.
2 - Jeffy The Sketch Artist: It took me quite a bit of thinking, but now I believe this deserves the rating it gets. One of the most aggravating Marvin torture videos to date.
1 - Jeffy’s Cat Throw Up: I mean, it’s obvious, isn’t it?
Mega post out of the way. But now it’s time for my last message to you all and SML itself…
Ever since the release of Cody’s Bad Word, I started seeing SML in a new, more problematic light. One that would change the way I would look at this show for the rest of my life. Learning about the drama, the constant controversies, seeing everyone in the show go against each other. It’s kind of like warfare in a way; chaos to say the least. And like I said above, Cody’s Hot Potion really did hit me unlike any other video did. I was very close to quitting, but to insure that wouldn’t happen so suddenly, I set a goal to see if March of 2023 would get an average of 5/10 or higher. If I would get lower than what I desired, I would quit. Thankfully that goal was reached. I decided to stay around longer to see what would happen next.
At the end of September 2023, I decided to join this wiki, where I could share my opinions about videos with others instead of just sharing them to my own. I found myself to be a pretty decent writer, and honestly my peak of that would be talking about videos I absolutely despised. The cat throw up review was my personal favorite, because I decided to show my true feelings for SML, and the same things that led to me quitting for good.
Now that we’ve reached 2024, I think it’s finally time to let go. Looking back, comparing SML to when I first stumbled upon it to what it is now is like comparing apples to oranges. They’re entirely different, but they share small similarities. When I take a look at the show now, and the tier list I just made, most of the videos are just… mediocre. Most videos just don’t tend to be enjoyable. And, honestly… what’s the purpose of even watching a show that you’ll predict not liking, or even getting a reaction out of it in some cases? What’s the purpose of watching if most of the characters are just unlikeable, and you can’t easily find someone to defend other than those tortured? It’s all just negativity now, and even if you can pinpoint specific videos that are good, the bad still greatly outweigh the good. But all that comes straight from the people who made this show to begin with. Someone who I think I should mention.
Logan Thirtyacre.
Logan. I doubt you’re reading this, and honestly I don’t think you’re even looking on this wiki, but if somehow you’re are magically reading this… let me settle things out. You aren’t a terrible person, but rather you are a person that is hard to understand. You started off your channel, not expecting too much. Until someone helped you gain popularity. On your own soon after, introducing new, popular characters, you would become really popular. You then introduced a certain someone that would both help, and MASSIVELY damage your channel. After you introduced him, after some time, you became more of a jerk. You mocked your fans, you ignored requests to improve things, etc. But one thing that stood by your personality the most: greed. You were desperate for more money, no matter if you had enough. You refused to remove Jeffy, because you were afraid you would lose money. With that being said, one of the reasons why you upload so much now compared to before is because you want more money. I understand for advertisements, even if they aren’t implemented well most of the time, but will you ever come to a point where you have… enough money? The reason why videos come out as mediocre at all is because you feel as if you’re pressured by your fans to do so. All I’m suggesting is… just, take a break. People are quitting because you don’t try enough. I feel like if you put in more effort into your videos, like, for example, one of your older videos, then maybe you can gain more praise. Take either a week or two apart from making videos, because you indeed have better things to do, like taking care of your daughter. Not saying you haven’t been, but still. This is just a suggestion from me. No harm whatsoever.
So anyways, that’s pretty much all I have to say. Even if my time on this wiki was short, I still had a decent time reviewing with you guys. But now that I’ve grown, I think it’s time to move on from things, with this included. It was fun while it lasted.
I’ll see you guys somewhere else, whether that be anywhere. Goodbye!
