Cody makes it to The House and makes several excuses to get his phone, and when he gets it, Marvin chases him down the street, while this is happening Cody calls Jackie Chu to tell him Marvin did sign it. Jeffy and Junior eat pizza. Marvin, furious that Jeffy ate pizza, wants Jeffy to receive the death penalty. Marvin forcibly drags Jeffy to court.
At the court, Judge Pooby starts the trial, where he explains that Jeffy is being tried for eating pizza without Marvin's permission and refusing to eat green beans and do his homework when he got all F's on his report card, which Marvin angrily confirms. Jeffy states that he hates green beans, doesn't wanna do his homework and wants to eat pizza, chocolate, chocolate cake, ice cream, cookies, and candy instead. Pooby decrees that Jeffy eats only great beans from now on and bans him from ever eating pizza, chocolate, chocolate cake, ice cream, cookies, or candy ever again. Marvin feels like not enough has been done and he still wants the pizza that Jeffy ate so he can burn it, and doesn't want him to experience happiness ever again, which Pooby states its impossible since it's already being digested, so Marvin wants Jeffy's poop to burn, which Pooby allows. He then dismisses the court.
Jeffy comes back home along with Marvin with a container with "poop" written on it, and explains to Rose about the whole situation, much to her disgust. The episode ends with Marvin desperately trying to get Jeffy to defecate.