All posts by UglyGrandma

5.5/10 Ok this might be a surprise to some but this video is missed potential as hell tbh.

Pros:

• The concept is great.

• Ronald for the most part was decent here, even if a few of his jokes dragged and he wasn't used well, he still had some funny moments throughout the video.

• Burger King's small cameo was funny.

• The scene with Brooklyn Guy distracting Simmons so he could launch a nuke at the moon was funny.

Neutral:

• The beginning of the Ronald scene before Steve mentioned the moon cheese had a couple funny moments like Ronald pretending to get down on his knees for Steve but it admittedly did drag on a little as well tbh.

Cons:

• The missed potential throughout this video hurts so much. This could've been such an awesome video where Jeffy and Ronald both get sent into space and they compete for the moon cheese. And I think honestly the video being extended to 14-15 minutes would've really worked for this. I know this is kinda like what dabhdude came up with and honestly I like his idea.

• The title is misleading as hell, Jeffy barely even does anything in the video (even though he could've like I mentioned above). This is absolutely a Brooklyn Guy video no question.

• The merch plugs at the beginning were annoying.

• The ending twist with the cheese just being regular cheese was so fucking rushed and stupid, it feels like Logan came up with that twist literally last minute.

Overall, this video really could've been something amazing, with Jeffy and Ronald both going on a space mission to steal the moon cheese, but instead it's wasted on just a bunch of talking again.

3.5/10 This video has some of the absolute worst missed potential in SML as a whole.

Pros:

• The concept is great.

• Bowser and Chef Pee Pee were both great here, I really like how both got a bit of a major role in the video.

• Junior was decent.

• The scene near the beginning with Bowser getting down to business was really funny.

Cons:

• Let's just quickly address the obvious: This video's missed potential is through the roof. Seeing Junior develop as a chef throughout the video and become a 5 star chef would've been awesome to watch but instead we got this underwhelming mess.

• And let's address the other obvious: Brooklyn Guy was fucking abysmal here. Literally all he did was come over to Junior's house, tell him a shitty pointless story, and then leave without helping him. I know Filler T. Guy has had many appearances like this in 2024 but this was some of the worst of it.

• Joseph was bad here as well, Joseph trying to literally kill Bowser just because Junior insulted his dad felt way too over-the-top and stupid.

• Cody and Timmy literally served no purpose in the video at all, if you cut their scenes out nothing would've changed in the video.

• The Nicktendo animation was really dumb and filler like usual.

• The ending was insanely abrupt.

Overall, this video was so goddamn disappointing, Filler T. Guy was at some of his worst here and the missed potential is so bad here. Also Joseph being randomly psychotic felt weird and Cody and Timmy served 0 purpose in the video.

1. 2021 (5.5/10)

2. 2022 (5.5/10)

3. 2023 (5.5/10)

4. 2020 (4.5/10)

5. 2024 (4/10)

Gotta say that I really overrated 2023 originally tbh, it has less problems than 2024 obviously but especially towards the end of the year you could tell the year was just becoming beta 2024.

Also 2021 and 2022 I feel have the least "offensively wrong" with them out of all the years, they're not good obviously but they didn't do anything memorably bad aside from maybe stuff like the 3 video a week schedule and Junior and Joseph's characterization (also early 2021 just being bland as hell). Also they hold the best months of the decade for me (June/July 2021 and March 2022).

4.5/10 This is a video I've been meaning to re-review for quite some time now, this video has one of the worst nosedives of any video ever.

Pros:

• Jeffy was amazing here, him being so over-the-top throughout the video was super entertaining to watch.

• Judge Pooby was also great here, his reactions to Jeffy beating the shit out of him were really funny.

• Judge Anthony was funny even if he wasn't on screen for a lot of the video.

• All of the scenes of Jeffy jumping Judge Pooby were really funny, this video really should've been an SML Short because this definitely would've been a good video if it was just that.

Cons:

• Brooklyn Guy was really bad here. His rambling throughout the video got on my nerves a lot, he definitely ruined the video.

• Rose blaming Marvin initially for what Jeffy did was annoying.

• The Nicktendo animation was boring and draggy like usual.

• The F22 joke was really stupid and annoying.

• The ending twist was insanely cheap, it felt like Logan just came up with something in a minute rather than actually cleverly thinking out the ending.

Overall, this video started off pretty good, but it fucking nosedived hard after the 5 minute mark. I don't know why the hell this couldn't just be an SML Short but of course every video's gotta be at least 10 minutes now.

6.5/10 This video was honestly super disappointing which really sucks.

Pros:

• The sets and costumes were fucking amazing in this video. Even if they weren't used to their full potential, I still loved the vibe of all of that.

• Jeffy, Marvin, and Penelope were decent here.

• The scenes with the 3 crawling through the vents were kinda cool.

• The stuff with Foxy towards the end was really good, that was definitely the highlight of the video outside of the sets/costumes.

Cons:

• The main problem with this video is that not a lot happens in terms of plot. Yes, the sets and costumes are pretty, but like, all the video really does is go around showing all of it off. I feel this video would've been a lot better if there was more actual horror included.

• Brooklyn Guy was honestly pretty mediocre here, he didn't have many funny jokes and the gag with him shocking Penelope was pretty annoying tbh.

• The ending 4th wall break was really stupid and unneeded.

Overall, this video was really disappointing for the finale of the FNAF series. While the sets and costumes were awesome, the actual video didn't really do a lot outside of that. This is for sure the weakest FNAF video without a doubt.