For me, I would rate the video a 4/10
3,065
pages
ALL POSTS
The Chain Letter!
Tagged Posts
Overall, December is a mediocre month. Content here is pretty much a hit or miss, from great videos to wasted and/or terrible ones. Still, that month and 2021 ended with "Brooklyn Guy The Rapper" on a reasonably good note. This is an improvement over last year's "Jeffy's New Year Resolution", which turned out awful and hammered the final nail to 2020's dubious coffin. Anyways, let's go over the video ratings for December.
Cody's Magic Wand!: ★★★★½ (4.5)
Joseph's Grandparents!: ½☆☆☆☆ (0.5)
Jeffy's Tree House!: ★★★☆☆ (3)
Brooklyn Guy The Babysitter!: ½☆☆☆☆ (0.5)
The Chain Letter!: ★☆☆☆☆ (1)
Elf On The Shelf!: ★★★★½ (4.5)
Brooklyn Guy's Christmas Problem!: ½☆☆☆☆ (0.5)
Jeffy's Gucci Xbox!: ★★★★☆ (4)
Brooklyn Guy The Rapper!: ★★★☆☆ (3)
Best Video: Elf On The Shelf!
Worst Video: Joseph's Grandparents!
Final Month Rating: 4.7/10
Perhaps, 2022 will be better than 2021 and 2020 for SML and as a whole.
Now let's go to 2021 as a whole. Overall, it is a mediocre year for SML. Like I said on the earlier mid-year review, 2021 started smoothly, but turned to rolling hills to steep mountains with many ups and downs. On one hand, we got hits like JAJGTP, Jeffy's Joyride, and SQUID GAME. On the other hand, we got misses like Jeffy Gets Ran Over, Jeffy's 17th Birthday, and Cody's Accident.
Ranking the months:
June (6.4/10)
October (6.2/10)
February (5.4/10)
November (5.3/10)
July (5.2/10)
March (5/10)
January (5/10)
May (5/10)
December (4.7/10)
September (4.3/10)
April (3.4/10)
August (3.3/10)
Top 10 Best Videos of 2021:
Jeffy And Junior Go To Prison! [★★★★★ (5)]
SQUID GAME [★★★★★ (5)]
Jeffy Plays Basketball! [★★★★★ (5)]
The Baby Alien! [★★★★★ (5)]
Jeffy’s Joyride! [★★★★★ (5)]
Elf On The Shelf [★★★★½ (4.5)]
Jeffy Plays Football! [★★★★½ (4.5)]
The Jewelry Heist! [★★★★½ (4.5)]
Cody's Magic Wand [★★★★½ (4.5)]
Junior's Cookie Crisp! [★★★★½ (4.5)]
Top 10 Worst Videos of 2021: (All are rated at 0)
10. The Pink Couch! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
9. The Mustache Problem! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
8. Cody’s Prank! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
7. TaKEN To Court! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
6. Brooklyn Guy’s Thanksgiving! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
5. Brooklyn Guy Pet Detective! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
4. Jeffy Gets Ran Over! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
3. Jeffy’s 17th Birthday! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
2. Don’t Tell Goodman! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
Cody’s Accident! [☆☆☆☆☆ (0)]
Overall Rating for 2021: 49.3/100
(Edited by LancerWikiEditor)
1: Cody's Magic Wand - 6.5/10
A decent video with a couple of jokes that missed.
2: Joseph's Grandparents - 6/10
One of those videos that is good for a couple laughs (albeit heavily carried by the ending) but that's about it.
3: Jeffy's Tree House - 5.5/10
Always sucks when there's a video with a fun first half and then it just falls off in the second half.
4: Brooklyn Guy The Babysitter - 4/10
Just a video with bland and mediocre jokes.
5: The Chain Letter - 6.5/10
Same as many other videos this month, just decent and that's it.
6: Elf On The Shelf - 6.5/10
One of the more unique Christmas specials concept wise and while it does deliver for the most part, a lot of the dialouge/jokes just felt super generic and cliche. Not enough to stop it from being decent though.
7: Brooklyn Guy's Christmas - 7/10
Nothing but a pretty standard, funny video.
8: Jeffy's Gucci Xbox - 7/10
By contrast, this is a rather unusual video that I think worked well.
9: Brooklyn Guy The Rapper - 5.5/10
Fitting for a final video for 2021, the last video is a polarizing one with strong positive and negative qualities alike, but I think the positive qualities slightly win out.
FAVORITE: Brooklyn Guy's Christmas and Jeffy's Gucci Xbox
LEAST FAVORITE: Brooklyn Guy The Babysitter
OVERALL: 6.06/10 (Decent). It's a fine enough, albeit somewhat disappointing end to a very polarizing year that was all over the place.
OVERALL SCORE FOR 2021: 5.94/10. Overall 2021 was a pretty polarizing year. It started strong, then started to become hit or miss after the C&D but then started to somewhat pick itself up in the final months. All in all, I'd consider it a borderline decent year; this is actually the highest score a year's gotten since 2016, which I definitely think is worth nothing.
All in all though I get the impression SML is starting to become more comfortable in it's new skin, and I do hope it finds its way by 2022.
BEST MONTH: July (6.7/10)
WORST MONTH: August (4.8/10)
All months of 2021 (Worst to best):
August (4.8/10)
May (5/10)
March (5.64/10)
February (5.75/10)
October (5.83/10)
April (6/10)
December (6.06/10)
September (6.1/10)
January (6.38/10)
June (6.5/10)
November (6.56/10)
July (6.7/10)
(Edited by Smleditorguy)
How the hell did I even call this video "very good?"
GOOD:
+Craig has returned, and he's good.
+The plot/concept is good.
NEUTRAL:
~Cody is OK.
~Brooklyn Guy is tolerable, at least, until he got drunk.
BAD:
-The concept execution is, TERRIBLE.
-Junior is annoying.
-The scene where Brooklyn Guy got drunk is terrible.
-Lots of unfunny, maddening moments.
UGLY:
--Joseph is SUPREMELY AWFUL!
--The ghost is EXTREMELY IRRITATING AS F___!
Overall, this is now a dumpster fire I would rather forget...
Final Rating: ★☆☆☆☆ (1)
(Edited by LancerWikiEditor)
20 Votes in Poll
December has been a really crappy month for Joseph’s character so far
Happy birthday to that amazing video and the best one from last year!!
Jeffy, Junior and Joseph are played by Lance, Logan and Lovell respectively.
Notice a pattern here?
NOTE: At the time of this review, I am unable to find a quality thumbnail to incorporate to it.
Not as great as I expected, but still a big improvement over the last one.
BEAUTIFUL:
++Craig is awesome! Hence the fact that this is a 666th episode.
GOOD:
+The second half is good.
+Cody is good.
+Brooklyn Guy is good.
+Chef Pee Pee is good.
+The plot/concept is great.
NEUTRAL:
~Brooklyn Guy is OK.
~The ghost is tolerable.
BAD:
-The first half is bad.
-Joseph is annoying.
-Junior is annoying.
-One minor nitpick here: The video could make more sense if it was released on October.
Overall, the video is pretty good but a 2-sided coin.
Final Rating: ★★★½☆ (3.5)
6.5/10 - While it didn’t reach my expectations, it’s still pretty decent
Pros:
Unique concept
Brooklyn T. Guy was good
The Ghost was a mix of good and bad
Cody was alright
Craig. It’s nice to see him back
Junior was okay
Cons:
The Ghost was a mix of good and bad
Drunk Brooklyn Guy will always be unfunny unless it’s done right (i.e: “Jeffy’s Treehouse” or “Jeffy’s New Year's Resolution”)
The New Years Scene fricking dragged for way too long
Joseph was kinda annoying