Plumber Guy should be Brooklyn Guy’s grandfather, and the dad of Barbara. Brooklyn Guy only called Plumber Guy his dad because Barbara and Mr. Guy probably divorced when Brooklyn was at very young age, and to cover it up, she got her dad to act as Brooklyn Guy’s father. Until Plumber Guy died, Brooklyn, Barbara, and Jonathan were at his funeral (maybe Debra or Brooklyn Guy’s first ex too) and Brooklyn Guy heard the Minister say that Barbara was his daughter. Then Brooklyn Guy found out. And that’s why he knows about his real dad, Mr. Guy.
42 Votes in Poll