Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving!

1. “Junior’s Sleepover Mission” is one of the most overrated SML videos ever, note that it’s not the most overrated (2.5/10)

2. “Joseph's Grandparents” is a bad video (3.5/10)

3. “Jeffy’s Teddy Bear” is underrated (7/10)

4. Junior was slightly more tolerable in “Junior’s Prank Gone Wrong” than in “Junior’s Revenge”

5. Tyrone (The “Black Lights Matter” Activist) was the only saving grace in “Jeffy’s Bad Word”

6. “Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving” was one of Karen's better appearances (although it’s very obvious it’s not her absolute best)

7. “Jeffy's Parents” is a decent video (6”5/10)

8. “Jeffy’s Birthday Wish” is my favorite Jeffy video (9.5/10)

9. ”A Crappy Thanksgiving” is the worst Thanksgiving special, yes I know I'm late lmao (3/10)

10. “Shrek’s Crappy Wish” is the grossest SML video

NOTE 1: Some of these videos' placements might eventually change in a future update as my opinion on them might change after a rewatch.

NOTE 2: These videos are placed in their tier lists not in order of preference, but in chronological order.

1. “Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving” is a mediocre video (4/10)

2. “Jeffy's Easter Eggs” is the most forgettable video of the year so far

3. ”Cody’s Accident” is the absolute worst of Cody

4. Penelope is (now) my 2nd least favorite character (again, behind Rosalina)

5. Junior is overrated

6. The first half of “Junior the Thief” is god awful

7. ”Junior’s Bodyguard” is underrated (8.5/10)

8. ”Joseph’s New Shell” is overrated (2.5/10)

9. Goodman is a great character (9/10)

10. ”Mr. Goodman's Clone” is underhated (3/10)

Despite the hate it gets, Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving is still a little underhated.

Someone gave it a 9.5, which is WAY too high imo.

Timely is my middle name.

1: No Nut November - 6.5/10

It's alright. That's really it.

2: Charleyyy Gets Arrested - 5.5/10

It's alright but apart from Charleyyy himself (who kinda carried the video), this video is entirely unremarkable and almost feels unfinished.

3: Jeffy's Show And Tell - 4/10

Generic bad SML video, stupid, unfunny halfassed comedy.

4: Junior The Simp - 7/10

Just standard funny Junior antics. The crazy lengths he goes for his love are unexpected and funny and that's really it.

5: Gold Jeffy - 7/10

Another fairly good video that I feel just works like it is. Except the beginning. Not a fan of that.

6: PJ Crenshaw - 7.5/10

This video has a bit of everything. A nice roster, funny idea, clever jokes and even a unexpected, slightly downtrodden ending.

7: Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving - 8/10

Most SML Thanksgiving specials are among my favorites of their respective years, this is no exception. Almost every line/joke here is delivered perfectly and the entire video is just full of chaos which I love.

8: The Baby Alien - 7/10

And a fairly good closer. The score might change a bit later but for now I think it's pretty good.

FAVORITE: Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving

LEAST FAVORITE: Jeffy's Show and Tell

OVERALL: 6.56/10 (Decent). I'll admit the first half wasn't too great but the second half really more than made up for it. Pretty consistently quality content from "Junior The Simp" onwards and I'm actually fairly optimistic for the future.

List:

• August (4.8/10)

• May (5/10)

• March (5.64/10)

• February (5.75/10)

• October (5.83/10)

• April (6/10)

• September (6.1/10)

• January (6.38/10)

• June (6.5/10)

• November (6.56/10)

• July (6.7/10)

November is just your average month overall. Based on the Animal Farm quote, many of these videos this month has great potential, but some turn out better than others. For example, the last two videos, Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving and The Baby Alien have my expectations for these high. In reality, the former failed them and became the worst Thanksgiving special while the latter met or even exceeded them. Anyways, let's go over the ratings of these videos!

• No Nut November!: ★☆☆☆☆ (1)

• Charleyyy Gets Arrested!: ★★★½☆ (3.5)

• Jeffy's Show and Tell!: ★½☆☆☆ (1.5)

• Junior The Simp!: ★★½☆☆ (2.5)

• Gold Jeffy!: ★★★½☆ (3.5)

• PJ Crenshaw!: ★★★★☆ (4)

• Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving!: ☆☆☆☆☆ (0)

• The Baby Alien!: ★★★★★ (5)

Best Video: The Baby Alien!

Worst Video: Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving!

Most Exceeded Video: Gold Jeffy! (By +1.5 stars)

Most Wasted Video: Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving! (By -4 stars)

Final Month Rating: 5.3/10

When December comes, I hope that month (and the very last video of 2021) ends this year in a high note.

#8: Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving! (1/10)

#7: No Nut November! (2.5/10)

#6: Jeffy's Show And Tell! (5/10)

#5: Junior The Simp! (5.5/10)

#4: PJ Crenshaw! (6.5/10)

#3: Charleyyy Gets Arrested! (7/10)

#2: Gold Jeffy! (7.5/10)

#1: The Baby Alien! (8.5/10)

Easy and simple

1. Black Yoshi’s Black Friday (2017) – I mean, it’s Black Yoshi. What do you expect lmao • 9/10 [S]

2. Turkey Tyranny (2016) – It’s good, but the beginning definitely carried this video • 8.5/10 [A]

3. The Big Thanksgiving (2014) – A bit overrated but I did enjoy it • 8/10 [A]

4. Bowser's Thanksgiving (2013) – Good but very forgettable, at least to me • 7/10 [A]

5. Mario's Thanksgiving Problem (2015) – It’s a video, that’s it • 6/10 [B]

6. Brooklyn Guy's Thanksgiving (2021) – I might be the only one who doesn’t think this video’s terrible lmao • 4/10 [D]

7. A Crappy Thanksgiving (2009) – Typical 2009 SML • 3/10 [E]

Brooklyn Guy’s Thanksgiving was an amazing video (no hate pls, cuz I know there might be some, just my opinion)

I have no idea what I was talking about when I said Brooklyn Guy’s Thanksgiving isn’t that bad. It’s fucking terrible.

0.5/10 What a messy Thanksgiving "Special" this is

Pros:

+Brooklyn guy was okay

Cons:

-Brooklyn Guy just got tortured for most of the video

-JONATHAN IS BACK WHY

-Brooklyn Guy's Mom is so annoying

-This video was SO boring

-Brooklyn Guy wanting to kill the chicken honestly felt too much like Woody wanting to kill the chicken in The Big Thanksgiving

-The video was very confusing as well

I am sorry but I could not even finish the video, I stopped at 5 minutes in, anyways this video was terrible