If we’re going the TAWOG approach where Larry didn’t do anything it all and it all just ascended into chaos the same thing would happen here because apparently the sml universe would ascend into chaos without Brooklyn Guy doing his jobs or him not being there

We would probably have Goodman doing the jobs like the old days.

Brooklyn Guy Gets Fired wouldn’t have happened if Brooklyn Guy didn’t exist.

Goodman would still become a rich asshole and quit almost all his jobs

There wouldn't be heavy filler with mediocre animations

Simmons and/or Earl would be the main cop(s)

Then we wouldn’t have anyone to stop Bad Things Guy