10. Scooter

9. Black Yoshi/Ya Boy Duggie

8. Rosalina’s/Rose’s Parents

7. Super D

6. Bowser/Braxton

5. Tito (General)

4. Harold Wilfred

3. Patrick

2. Craig The Devil

1. Chef Pee Pee

1. Chef Pee Pee

2. Duggie

3. Craig

4. Braxton

5. Tito

6. Patrick

7. Rose's Parents

8. Harold

9. Super D

10. Scooter

1. Chef Pee Pee

2. Duggie

3. Braxton

4. Craig

5. Tito

6. Patrick

7. Scooter

8. The Alien and his wife

Unratable:

For Harold, he can't come back because in the Jeffy's Butler 2 video, it was referenced on the sticky note that he died.

For Super D, he should absolutely NEVER come back! Plus, he shouldn't be considered to be even close to the same level as the other characters mentioned.

I never thought about the sticky notes being possibly related to the characters, but that’s POSSIBLY, not confirmed. Most of these characters have died at least once before anyways. And Super D was pretty recurring at the end of 2020 and the beginning of 2021, and has likely had more screen time than a minority of the characters (although I don’t really like him so there’s one thing we can agree on)