Thread:TortoiseCat5/@comment-27171758-20200214062730

Hi, I would to question you on the heroes, villains and antagonists category, and it is because you haven't been seen editing since January this year. I have been talking to Agonzo and MarioFan2009 about this and Agonzo said the villain and hero categories are useless, and MarioFan2009 said he was not sure about this.

So, what should we do with those categories? I feel the staff of this wiki should make a final consensus about it since almost everyone would fall under each category including the main characters, recurring characters, etc., and I have a few options about this. I suggest we either remove the heroes, villains and antagonists category from characters who are occasionally both villains and heroes and the categories can just have characters who are actual villains or always villains (for the Villains category), characters who are always heroes (for the Heroes category) and characters who are antagonistic but not evil (for the Antagonists category since antagonist does not always equal villain), and the Anti-Heroes category can be for characters who are half good and half bad or just remove the categories entirely. I'm suggesting this because I'm getting tired of users arguing about those kind of things, and I want this wiki to have a policy saying that arguing with other about who's good and who's bad is prohibited. Since almost everyone in the series including the main characters can be both protagonists/heroes and villains/antagonists, it is kind of reduntant to list everyone in each of those mentioned categories (and not just one).

The problem is almost everyone in the series can be villainous, even the ones who are clearly heroes and protagonists. For example, Mario, Bowser Junior, Brooklyn T. Guy, Jeffy, Bowser, Black Yoshi, etc. are all protagonists, but they are either occasionally or sometimes antagonists, and most of the characters such as the main characters or the protagonists constantly change their roles. 2 examples are characters such as Black Yoshi, Bowser, Craig the Devil, etc. are villains most of the time, but they are sometimes heroes, while characters such as Mario, Brooklyn T. Guy, etc. are heroes most of the time, but they are sometimes villains. This is kind of like Looney Tunes since pretty much all characters in both Looney Tunes and SML are both villains and heroes on several occasions, and the Looney Tunes Wiki does not allow any categories called Villains, Heroes, Protagonists, Antagonists or Anti-Heroes since the staff of that wiki agreed to remove the categories entirely I think because almost everyone would fall under each category because they are both villains and heroes, and both protagonists and antagonists on several occasions.

Do you have an opinion on this? 