Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27171758-20190327002834

Alright, I've been getting really frustrated with users edit-warring on villain, hero, neutral and antagonist stuff, and I have had enough of it. I feel like we should have a policy about antagonists, villains, heroes, neutral characters or anti-heroes on this wiki.

If you feel like a character does not qualify as a hero, an antagonist or a villain, you need to explain why instead of making childish edit-wars about it. Before removing a character from the categories (Villains, antagonists, heroes,etc.), I'll explain why they count as either of them.

For example, Jeffy is a protagonist, but he is sometimes an antagonist because he annoys/tortures Mario, he swears, he acts rude to Mario and Rosalina, he makes Mario hit Goodman's car in The Fender Bender, he locks Mario out of the house in Locked Out, he tells lies to Mario, he sometimes diobeys Mario and he, along with Junior, were rude to Cody in The Test.

Another example is that characters like Mario or Brooklyn T. Guy are heroes most of the time, but sometimes, they are villains due to being criminals.

Another example is that a few characters such as Black Yoshi and Bowser are villains most of the time, but sometimes, they are heroes, meaning that are considered anti-heroes.

This has also made me think of the idea of this wiki having a category called "Half hero and half villain" since almost every single character in the SML franchise is both a villain and a hero. Because of this, there should be a category for characters who are both heroes and villains (i.e. Mario, Bowser, Brooklyn T. Guy, Black Yoshi, Bowser Junior,etc.), and if the edit-warring continues, we could create a half villain and half hero category, but if that edit-war happens again if the category is created, then I will suggest that one of the admins will delete the villain, hero, anti-hero and antagonist categories entirely. However, if we keep the villains category, we'll have it for actual villains only (i.e. Does Bad Things Guy, Nancy, the Loan Dolphin, Principal Steinbeck,etc.), but if the edit-warring happens non-stop, we'll just have to remove the category entirely.

Also, there has been character role fussing (i.e. antagonist, dueteragonist,etc.) on characters (Goodman, Bowser, Black Yoshi,etc.), and there was edit-warring on characters' alignments ages ago (i.e. Mario, Brooklyn T. Guy, Goodman, Black Yoshi, Bowser,etc.)

Please comment on your opinion on these suggestions and explain why.

Note: I made a new thread because no one has voted or replied in a long time. 